Insurer Owes No Defense Costs in Former Director Suit

Businesses with insured-versus-insured exclusions in their liability policies may have to pay their own legal defense when a former manager sues.

Updated on Nov. 3, 2026 in Insurance

Insurer Owes No Defense Costs in Former Director Suit

The Tenth Circuit ruled that Twin City Fire Insurance Co., a subsidiary of Hartford Insurance Group, is not liable for legal costs Tri County Telephone Association Inc. incurred defending a former director's suit over the company's acquisition. The unsigned, unpublished ruling, issued Tuesday, applies an insured-versus-insured exclusion in the insurer's policy.

Why it matters

The decision turns on a policy exclusion that bars coverage when one insured sues another, and the court found it applies even to suits brought by former managers, with no carveout for that group. For businesses and their directors, it shows how an insured-versus-insured clause can leave a company paying its own defense costs in a dispute with a former leader.

The ruling is an unsigned, unpublished opinion, which means it does not set binding precedent beyond this case. No dollar amounts for the defense costs at issue were reported in the source.

The players

Twin City Fire Insurance Co.

A property and casualty insurer, a subsidiary of Hartford Insurance Group, that sells business liability policies whose exclusions determine when companies receive coverage for lawsuits.

Tri County Telephone Association Inc.

A Wyoming-based telecommunications company whose members and customers depend on the local provider for phone and internet service, and which sought insurance coverage for its legal defense.

Hartford Insurance Group

A large insurance company whose subsidiaries sell commercial and personal policies to businesses and households across the United States.

The details

Twin City Fire Insurance Co.'s policy contains an exclusion for suits in which one insured person or entity sues another. Tri County Telephone Association was sued by a former director over the company's acquisition, and sought coverage for its legal defense. The Tenth Circuit found the exclusion applied, which meant the insurer had no obligation to cover those costs, and it affirmed the lower court's decision. The court also held that the exclusion contains no exception for suits brought by former managers.

Timeline

  1. Tuesday, November 3, 2026: The Tenth Circuit issued its ruling on the coverage exclusion.

Money Landscape

Insured-versus-insured exclusions are common in business liability policies and are often a central issue when companies and their former officers end up in litigation. This Wyoming case shows how courts apply that language to suits brought by former managers.

Business owners and directors should check whether their liability and D&O policies contain insured-versus-insured exclusions and how those clauses apply to former managers. Households and small businesses that hold similar policies may want to review the exclusions with a qualified insurance professional before a dispute arises.

The takeaway

Insured-versus-insured exclusions can leave a company paying its own defense costs when a former director sues it, so the wording of these clauses matters. Before a dispute arises, review your liability policy's exclusions and discuss them with a qualified insurance or legal professional.

Further reading

For broader context on how liability coverage works, see the Wyoming Insurance section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.