Court Narrows Landslide Exclusion for Homeowners
Texas homeowners on sloped lots may see insurers challenged when a collapse has mixed natural and human causes.
Updated on Nov. 1, 2026 in Insurance

Live Poll
Do you think insurers should cover landslide damage unless it is purely natural?
A Texas appeals court overturned a summary judgment that had favored two Travis County homeowners in a backyard landslide insurance dispute with Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange (PURE). The case was sent back to the 250th District Court of Travis County for further hearings and evidence.
Why it matters
The ruling means a homeowners insurer's earth movement and landslide exclusion may be read narrowly, so coverage for a slope collapse can depend on whether natural events alone caused it. For Texas homeowners on hillside or creek-side lots, the case shows that a denied claim can stay contested in court for years, with the outcome hinging on expert geotechnical findings.
The slope collapse extended roughly 80 feet down toward a creek and left both homes unsafe. The appeals court reversed the summary judgment and the related award of statutory interest under the Texas Prompt Payment of Claims Act.
The players
Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange (PURE)
A homeowners insurer whose earth movement and landslide exclusion was at the center of the coverage denial and appeal.
Third Court of Appeal
The Texas appellate court in Austin that reversed the summary judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings.
250th District Court of Travis County
The Texas trial court that originally granted summary judgment to the homeowners and will hear the case on remand.
The details
PURE denied the claims by citing a standard earth movement and landslide exclusion in the homeowners policies. The appeals court held that the exclusion applies only when natural events alone cause the landslide, and that exclusion clauses must be read strictly against the insurer. Because expert reports disagreed on whether construction, drainage changes or land management contributed, the court found the policy did not clearly exclude a collapse caused by mixed natural and human-related events. The case returns to the 250th District Court of Travis County to resolve that factual question.
Timeline
- The Third Court of Appeal issued its ruling on October 30, 2026.
Money Landscape
Coverage disputes over earth movement exclusions tend to hinge on the exact wording of each policy and the expert evidence presented. This ruling shows that Texas courts can reverse early wins for policyholders when causation is still contested.
Homeowners with hillside, creek-side or sloped properties should review whether their policy contains an earth movement or landslide exclusion and how it is worded. Discussing coverage gaps with a licensed insurance agent or qualified professional is a sensible next step.
The takeaway
Insurance exclusions are read narrowly against insurers when causes are mixed, so the wording of a landslide clause can decide a claim. Keep your policy's earth movement terms on file and ask an insurance professional how they apply to your lot.
Further reading
For more on how policy exclusions shape claim outcomes, see Insurance coverage guides.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Times of India.
Live Poll
Do you think insurers should cover landslide damage unless it is purely natural?





