Disallowed Deductions Spark $15.6 Million Tax Bill
Taxpayers who claim business write-offs on side ventures should document a genuine profit motive to avoid similar IRS penalties.
Updated on Nov. 5, 2026 in Taxes

The IRS determined that Michael Cioffi's Italian hotel, Monteverdi Tuscany, was not a legitimate business and assessed more than $15.6 million in back taxes and penalties after disallowing business deductions he claimed over six years. Cioffi, a partner at Blank Rome LLP in Cincinnati, disputes the IRS determination.
Why it matters
The ruling shows how the IRS can reject business deductions for a property if it concludes the activity is not a genuine business, turning years of claimed write-offs into a large tax bill with penalties. For Cincinnati taxpayers who own side ventures or vacation properties, the case underscores why documented intent to profit matters.
The IRS assessed more than $15.6 million in back taxes and penalties after disallowing business deductions claimed over six years. The figure reflects the combined total of tax owed and penalties on those disallowed deductions.
The players
Internal Revenue Service (IRS)
The federal agency that collects taxes, sets rules for which business deductions are allowed, and assesses back taxes and penalties when it disallows claimed write-offs.
Blank Rome LLP
A national law firm whose attorneys, including Michael Cioffi, handle mass torts and complex disputes for clients.
The details
The IRS concluded that Monteverdi Tuscany, a boutique hotel, resort, and spa in Castiglioncello del Trinoro, Italy, did not qualify as a legitimate business. Once that conclusion was reached, the deductions Cioffi claimed against the property were disallowed, which raised his taxable income for each affected year. Back taxes were then assessed on that income, and penalties were added on top, producing a total above $15.6 million.
Timeline
Over six years, Cioffi claimed business deductions that the IRS later disallowed.
On November 5, 2026, the story on the IRS determination and tax assessment was published.
Money Landscape
IRS scrutiny of whether ventures are genuine businesses or personal pursuits has long shaped how high-income taxpayers claim losses. This assessment shows that the agency will pursue those determinations even for property held abroad.
Anyone claiming business deductions on a side venture, second property, or hobby-like activity should keep records showing a genuine profit motive. If the IRS disallows those deductions, the resulting tax and penalties can be substantial, so it is worth reviewing your own documentation with a qualified tax professional.
The takeaway
A large IRS assessment can follow years of disallowed deductions, so keeping clear records of profit intent for any side business is worth doing. If you are unsure whether a venture qualifies, a conversation with a qualified tax professional is a practical next step.
Further reading
For background on how the IRS decides which deductions hold up, explore more Taxes coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.



