Two Trees Faces Class-Action Rent Lawsuit

Tenants at 300 Ashland Place allege the landlord bypassed rent increase limits, potentially impacting their monthly costs.

Updated on Oct. 30, 2026 in Apartments

Bold flat-color editorial illustration featuring a minimalist archway, evoking the institutional tension of urban housing and rent stabilization policy.
A class-action lawsuit filed against developer Two Trees alleges the firm illegally bypassed rent stabilization limits at its 300 Ashland Place complex. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should large landlords be allowed to use rent concessions to bypass rent increase limits?

A class-action lawsuit filed on October 24, 2026, alleges that developer Two Trees illegally inflated rents at its 300 Ashland Place complex. The suit claims the firm calculated lease renewals based on higher legal rent amounts rather than discounted preferential rates.

Why it matters

Tenants in buildings receiving the 421a property tax break are entitled to rent-stabilized protections and strict limits on annual increases. This dispute highlights how rent calculation methods can significantly impact household housing costs beyond authorized city guidelines.

The lawsuit alleges Two Trees collected $30 million in excess rent over five years, contradicting the 3.25% annual increase limit imposed by the city since 2021.

The players

Two Trees

A real estate developer and manager that owns more than 4,000 apartments across New York City.

Rent Guidelines Board

The municipal body responsible for setting the annual maximum allowable rent increases for regulated housing.

The details

The lawsuit claims Two Trees used rent concessions to lower the initial price of units, then applied authorized percentage hikes to the much higher legal rent rather than the actual paid price. By ignoring the preferential rent when calculating renewals, the developer allegedly imposed increases far exceeding the 3.25% maximum allowed by the city. This mechanism can effectively force tenants into paying significant premiums that violate local rent stabilization rules governing buildings tied to the 421a tax break.

Timeline

  1. The 300 Ashland Place complex opened in 2016.

  2. The city Rent Guidelines Board stopped approving rent hikes above 3.25% in 2021.

  3. The 421a property tax break program expired in 2022.

  4. The class-action lawsuit against Two Trees was filed on October 24, 2026.

  5. The 421a tax break deadline for building construction is 2031.

Money Landscape

This case centers on the long-term compliance requirements associated with the 421a property tax break program. It marks a significant legal challenge to how landlords manage rent-stabilized portfolios following the expiration of that specific tax benefit in 2022.

Tenants in buildings once covered by tax breaks should review their original lease riders to confirm whether they were charged on legal versus preferential rent amounts. If you believe your renewal offers have exceeded city-mandated limits, consult with a qualified housing attorney or legal professional.

The takeaway

This case serves as a reminder to verify that rent increases on your lease renewals align with official city caps regardless of the concessions offered at move-in. Keep a comprehensive file of all initial lease agreements and subsequent renewal offers to identify discrepancies in rent calculations.

Further reading

For more on local housing regulations, review our Apartments section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Gothamist.

Live Poll

Should large landlords be allowed to use rent concessions to bypass rent increase limits?