Retirement Plan Members Get $650,000 Settlement
Eligible Republic Mortgage employees in the profit-sharing plan will receive payments covering about half of their investment losses.
Updated on Nov. 4, 2026 in Retirement Planning

A federal judge gave final approval to a class action settlement of up to $650,000 for employees in the Republic Mortgage Insurance Company retirement plan. The suit alleged plan managers failed to meet ERISA duties in managing a guaranteed investment account.
Why it matters
The lawsuit claimed plan managers did not remove the Guaranteed Investment Account option after December 2021, a step that was alleged to have left workers exposed to financial losses. The settlement resolves those claims without the company admitting wrongdoing, and it covers roughly half of the losses calculated across the affected group.
The settlement of up to $650,000 covers approximately 50 percent of about $1.3 million in losses across roughly 100 plan members. Court-approved costs include $214,450 in legal fees, $25,000 for the independent financial representative and $11,835 for administrator operating costs.
The players
Republic Mortgage Insurance Company
A mortgage insurer whose employee profit-sharing retirement plan was the subject of the settlement, and which is closing its mortgage insurance business through a run-off period.
Matt B. Allison
A former Republic Mortgage employee who served as lead plaintiff in a suit over the management of retirement plan investments.
Catherine C. Eagles
A senior federal district judge in the Middle District of North Carolina who approved the settlement, which is paid from retirement accounts workers rely on.
Atticus
The settlement administrator that will calculate each eligible member's share and distribute payments from the settlement fund.
The details
The settlement amount will be paid directly into the retirement accounts of eligible plan members who did not opt out. The settlement administrator, Atticus, will calculate each eligible member's share and distribute the approved payments according to the court-accepted plan. The lawsuit was brought by lead plaintiff Matt B. Allison under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, which sets fiduciary standards for employer-sponsored retirement plans.
Timeline
December 2021: plan managers allegedly failed to remove the Guaranteed Investment Account option.
Late 2024: class action lawsuit officially filed.
October 16, 2026: fairness hearing held.
November 2, 2026: Judge Catherine C. Eagles gave final approval to the settlement.
Money Landscape
Settlements under ERISA fiduciary claims are a recurring way that participants recover losses when plan investment options are managed poorly. This case shows how individual plan members can pursue recovery when retirement accounts lose value through decisions made by plan managers.
Plan members who did not opt out will receive payments from the settlement fund, with each share calculated by the administrator. Workers with retirement accounts should review how their plan's investment options are managed and discuss any questions about their own accounts with a qualified financial professional.
The takeaway
Retirement plan losses from managed investment options can sometimes be recovered through class action settlements, but payments are typically a share of total losses rather than a full reimbursement. Plan members who have questions about their own accounts should speak with a qualified financial or tax professional.
Further reading
For background on how plan options are set and monitored, explore Retirement Planning coverage.



