NC Retirement Pension Repurchase Limits Upheld
Retirees remain capped at five years of service credit repurchases following the court's latest decision.
Updated on Oct. 29, 2026 in Retirement Planning
Live Poll
Should government retirement systems be allowed to change rules that limit benefits for current participants?
The North Carolina Court of Appeals recently affirmed the dismissal of a retired teacher's challenge to state retirement system rules. The ruling confirms that the Office of Administrative Hearings does not have the legal jurisdiction to decide if legislative amendments to pension laws violate contractual rights.
Why it matters
This decision clarifies the legal limitations for state employees seeking to challenge changes to their retirement benefits. It underscores that administrative bodies cannot rule on constitutional claims, effectively restricting how retirees can contest legislative changes to service credit policies.
State law now limits public employees to repurchasing no more than 5 years of service credit. This rule remains in place despite a challenge from a retiree who had sought to repurchase 7.3 years of credit.
The players
North Carolina Court of Appeals
The state's intermediate appellate court that hears appeals from state administrative agencies and superior courts.
Department of State Treasurer
The agency responsible for managing the North Carolina retirement system and interpreting its benefits administration.
Richard Lemaster
A retired North Carolina teacher whose petition challenged the state's revised pension repurchase limitations.
The details
The dispute centers on a 2021 repeal of the former statute governing service-credit repurchases, which was replaced in 2022 with a new formula that enforces a 5-year cap. When the Department of State Treasurer applied this cap to the petitioner, the retiree challenged the change, arguing that the legislation impaired vested contractual rights. The court held that because administrative agencies only possess powers expressly granted by statute, they lack the authority to rule on constitutional questions, effectively shutting down this specific avenue for challenging benefit revisions.
Timeline
The petitioner originally joined the state retirement system in 1996.
The petitioner returned to his teaching career in 2011.
State officials provided initial repurchase estimates between 2018 and 2019.
The General Assembly repealed the original retirement repurchase statute in 2021.
The revised repurchase law with the 5-year cap became effective in 2022.
Money Landscape
This decision reinforces the current framework governing public pension benefits in North Carolina. It confirms that statutory changes made by the General Assembly are not currently subject to reversal through administrative hearings.
Public employees should review their current service credit status to determine if they are affected by the 5-year repurchase cap. If you believe legislative changes to your benefits have caused financial harm, consider consulting with a legal professional who specializes in contract or employment law.
The takeaway
This ruling highlights the difficulty of challenging state pension policy changes through administrative channels. Retirees should verify their total service credit calculations with the Department of State Treasurer to ensure they understand how current caps apply to their specific retirement timeline.
Further reading
For more information on navigating your pension benefits, visit our Retirement Planning section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by North Carolina Lawyers Weekly.
Live Poll
Should government retirement systems be allowed to change rules that limit benefits for current participants?
