Michigan Court Protects Home Buyers After Inspections
Buyers can negotiate price reductions based on property defects without fearing a breach of contract lawsuit.
Updated on Oct. 26, 2026 in Residential
Live Poll
Should home buyers be legally protected when requesting price reductions after a home inspection reveals defects?
The Michigan Court of Appeals has overturned a $1.55 million judgment against a couple who sought a price reduction after a 2020 home inspection. The court ruled that requesting a discount following professional findings of property defects does not violate a standard purchase contract.
Why it matters
This decision provides important legal clarity for Michigan home buyers who use inspection contingencies to address unforeseen repairs. It prevents buyers from facing massive financial liability simply for seeking price adjustments when documented defects arise during the escrow process.
The overturned $1.55 million judgment included resale value losses, holding costs, and legal interest, relative to the home's original $1.275 million sale price. The buyers had initially requested a $150,000 price reduction to cover necessary repairs.
The players
Michigan Court of Appeals
The state-level judicial body that interprets contract law and sets legal precedents for property transactions across Michigan.
The details
The dispute began when buyers exercised a standard inspection contingency to identify property defects. After requesting a $150,000 price cut, the sellers refused, claiming the buyers breached the contract by not closing at the original price. The appeals court determined the lower court judge misunderstood the inspection terms, establishing that seeking a price correction for defects does not constitute a breach.
Timeline
In 2020, the buyers agreed to purchase the home for $1.275 million.
On October 23, 2026, the Michigan Court of Appeals overturned the judgment.
Money Landscape
This ruling clarifies the scope of the Michigan home inspection contingency standard, preventing sellers from successfully suing for breach when buyers negotiate based on inspection findings. It reaffirms that property sale contracts typically include a right to negotiate terms if a professional inspection reveals unexpected defects.
If you are currently under contract for a home in Michigan, ensure your inspection contingency clause is explicitly written to allow for price negotiations. Always consult with a qualified real estate attorney before refusing to close on a property based on inspection findings to ensure your contractual rights are protected.
The takeaway
The court's decision establishes that requesting a price adjustment following a professional home inspection is a legitimate exercise of contract rights. Home buyers should always document all property defects found during inspection and discuss negotiation strategies with a qualified professional to avoid potential litigation.
Further reading
For more information on navigating the purchasing process, see Residential.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Times of India.
Live Poll
Should home buyers be legally protected when requesting price reductions after a home inspection reveals defects?
