Court Ruling Clarifies Insurance Claim Disputes
Louisiana homeowners must provide clear proof of loss to successfully challenge insurer payouts in bad-faith litigation.
Updated on Oct. 22, 2026 in Insurance
Live Poll
Do you trust that insurance companies act in good faith when assessing your property damage claims?
The US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed a jury verdict favoring AIG on February 10, 2026, in a long-standing insurance bad-faith case. The ruling clarifies the legal requirements for policyholders to successfully prove an insurer withheld payment in bad faith.
Why it matters
This appellate decision underscores the high legal threshold homeowners must meet to prove bad faith, specifically concerning the timely submission of satisfactory proof of loss. It highlights the importance of documentation for policyholders pursuing large insurance claims following major storm events.
A final appraisal process established the hurricane damage at $16,126,268, significantly higher than the initial $309,479.21 payment the insurer issued after applying a $50,000 deductible.
The players
AIG
An international insurance corporation that provides property and casualty coverage for residential and commercial assets.
US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
The federal appellate body responsible for overseeing judicial proceedings across Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas.
The details
The dispute arose after the insurer initially paid $309,479.21 for property damage, while the homeowners sought payment based on a $6.7 million repair estimate. During the trial, the court excluded the final $16.1 million appraisal award from the jury's consideration, ruling that the insurer could not have acted in bad faith by refusing to pay a sum that was not yet determined. Consequently, the jury found the plaintiffs failed to prove the insurer received satisfactory proof of loss.
Timeline
August 2021: Hurricane Ida damaged the property in Thibodaux.
November 11, 2021: Plaintiffs submitted an initial $6,713,922 repair estimate.
January 2023: The lawsuit was originally filed in the district court.
February 10, 2026: The US Court of Appeals upheld the jury verdict.
Money Landscape
This case highlights the complexities of insurance recovery following major weather disasters in Louisiana. It reaffirms the standard that policyholders must provide clear, verified proof of loss to successfully challenge insurer payouts under current legal frameworks.
Homeowners should maintain detailed, itemized records of damage and professional repair estimates to establish formal proof of loss immediately after a disaster. Consulting with a licensed public adjuster or an insurance attorney can help ensure documentation meets the strict standards required for valid claims.
The takeaway
The appellate court's decision emphasizes that insurers generally are not liable for bad faith if they lack knowledge of a final appraisal amount during the initial claims process. Homeowners should maintain comprehensive records and coordinate closely with professionals when filing substantial claims.
Further reading
For more on managing coverage after natural disasters, see our Insurance section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Times of India.
Live Poll
Do you trust that insurance companies act in good faith when assessing your property damage claims?
