Low-Limit Drivers Face Million-Dollar Claim Risk
A $10,000 bodily injury limit became a more-than-$1,000,000 jury award in a Florida case that now heads back to trial.
Updated on Nov. 6, 2026 in Insurance

Live Poll
Do you trust insurance companies to treat policyholders fairly when settling claims?
The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals revived a bad faith claim against Progressive American Insurance Company, ruling 2-1 that the insurer must face a jury over how it handled a September 2016 Florida rear-end collision. The ruling sends the case back for trial after a jury had already awarded more than $1,000,000 against a policyholder who carried only $10,000 in bodily injury coverage.
Why it matters
The case shows how an insurer's handling of a claim can expose a policyholder to losses far above their policy limits, which is a risk drivers with minimum coverage often do not consider. It also puts Florida's total-loss rules and the duty insurers owe their policyholders under the spotlight.
The jury award exceeded $1,000,000 against a policyholder with $10,000 in bodily injury coverage, roughly 100 times the policy limit. The appeals court split 2-1 in reversing summary judgment that had favored the insurer.
The players
Progressive American Insurance Company
A major auto insurer whose claim-handling and settlement conditions are now the subject of a bad faith trial.
Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals
The federal appeals court whose 2-1 ruling revived the claim and sent the case back for trial.
The details
Progressive determined the driver was entirely at fault and agreed to settle for $10,000 in injuries and $5,000 for the car. The insurer attached two conditions, requiring a release signed by the injured motorist's wife and a handover of the car title. Progressive named the motorist's ex-wife on the release instead of the wife, and it reached that name through an internet and database search without calling the wife directly. Because Progressive treated the 1991 Mercedes, purchased for $3,000, as a write-off under Florida's total-loss statute, the claimant's side argued the release and title demands went beyond a fair settlement. Those disputed steps are the basis for the bad faith claim now headed back to a jury.
Timeline
September 2016: The driver rear-ended another motorist in Florida.
November 5, 2026: The Eleventh Circuit ruled Progressive must face a jury.
Money Landscape
Bad faith litigation against insurers has become a recurring way for injured parties to pursue amounts beyond low policy limits, especially when a claim is handled aggressively. This ruling adds to that pattern by showing a federal appeals court willing to let such a dispute reach a jury.
Drivers whose policies carry low bodily injury limits could face personal exposure if an insurer's handling of a claim later leads to a judgment above those limits. Reviewing your coverage levels against your assets is a useful step, and a conversation with a licensed insurance professional can help you judge whether your limits fit your situation.
The takeaway
A policy's stated limit does not always cap what a driver can owe, because claim-handling disputes can lead to judgments far above it. Florida drivers may want to review their bodily injury limits and discuss the appropriate level with a licensed insurance professional.
Further reading
For more on how policy limits and claim handling affect drivers, see the Insurance section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Insurance Business.
Live Poll
Do you trust insurance companies to treat policyholders fairly when settling claims?





