Florida Auto Policyholders Get $46M in Refunds
Infinity Auto policyholders who held coverage in 2023 through 2025 can expect refund checks as the state enforces its excess-profit rule.
Updated on Nov. 2, 2026 in Insurance

Live Poll
Do you trust Florida car insurers to charge fair prices without state intervention?
Florida Insurance Commissioner secured a refund of more than $46 million in excess profits from Infinity Auto Insurance Company to its policyholders. The refunds cover calendar and accident years 2023, 2024, and 2025, and Floridians who held Infinity auto policies during that period are the ones who stand to receive them.
Why it matters
Florida law requires insurers to return excess profits when underwriting gains over the three most recent calendar-accident years exceed anticipated underwriting profits plus five percent of earned premiums. The refund shows how that statutory test can translate into money returned to auto policyholders, and it signals that other auto insurers are approaching the same threshold.
Infinity Auto Insurance Company will refund more than $46 million in excess profits to policyholders covering 2023, 2024, and 2025. The refund is triggered when underwriting gains over the three most recent calendar-accident years exceed anticipated profits plus five percent of earned premiums.
The players
Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
The state regulator that oversees insurers and receives the financial data used to test whether companies owe policyholders excess-profit refunds.
Infinity Auto Insurance Company
An auto insurer whose Florida policyholders are receiving more than $46 million in excess-profit refunds under state law.
The details
Under Florida law, the test compares an insurer's actual underwriting gains across the three most recent calendar-accident years against what it expected to earn, plus a five percent cushion on premiums it collected. When actual gains exceed that line, the insurer must return the excess. Infinity Auto reviewed its finances and supplied data to the Office of Insurance Regulation, and the commissioner then secured the $46 million refund. Infinity Auto is expected to issue the refunds within 60 days.
Timeline
Calendar and accident years 2023, 2024, and 2025 are covered by the excess profits.
Infinity Auto is expected to issue refunds within 60 days.
Money Landscape
Florida's excess-profit statute ties insurer refunds to a measurable underwriting threshold rather than a fixed rebate schedule. With other auto insurers reported to be approaching that threshold, more refund announcements for Florida policyholders are expected in the near term.
Florida drivers who held Infinity Auto policies in 2023, 2024, or 2025 may receive a refund check, and returned checks will be pursued by the insurer. Policyholders should watch for the refund within the expected 60-day window and keep current contact information on file with their insurer.
The takeaway
Excess-profit refunds are tied to a statutory formula, so they can arrive without a claim. Policyholders who moved or changed contact details should confirm their address with their insurer so a refund check is not returned.
What happens next
Infinity Auto Insurance is expected to issue refunds within 60 days, and more Florida refund announcements are anticipated.
Further reading
For more on how auto coverage and premiums are set, see Insurance in our personal finance coverage.
Live Poll
Do you trust Florida car insurers to charge fair prices without state intervention?





