HOA Neighbors Can Recover Legal Fees in Noise Disputes

Arizona homeowners in communities with fee-shifting clauses may recover reasonable legal costs when they prevail in nuisance claims.

Updated on Nov. 3, 2026 in Apartments

Gouache-painted editorial illustration of a single air conditioning unit against a pale stucco patio wall in bright desert light, evoking home-disturbance disputes.
Arizona's Supreme Court ruled that HOA neighbors John and Anita Dryja may recover reasonable legal fees after prevailing in an air conditioner noise dispute under their community's fee-shifting clause. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should the losing party in a neighbour lawsuit always pay the winner's legal fees?

The Arizona Supreme Court reversed a lower-court decision that denied attorney fees to neighbors John and Anita Dryja in a dispute over air conditioner noise, finding the community agreement made fee recovery mandatory for the prevailing party. The case returns to Pima County Superior Court to determine a reasonable fee amount.

Why it matters

The ruling clarifies that homeowners in communities governed by recorded CC&Rs may recover legal costs when they successfully defend against nuisance claims that enforce those restrictions. For Arizona households living under HOA rules, it signals that litigation expenses can shift to the losing party when the governing agreement says so.

The dispute involved a $60,000 fee award to the association after a three-day trial in Pima County Superior Court. The fee amount owed to the Dryjas will be set by the trial court on remand.

The players

Arizona Supreme Court

The state's highest court, whose rulings set binding precedent on how HOA governing documents and fee-shifting clauses are enforced for Arizona homeowners.

Moondance Estates Community Association

The homeowners association whose assessments and CC&Rs govern residents' obligations, including nuisance rules and legal cost recovery.

The details

The Moondance Estates recorded CC&Rs prohibit nuisances and allow residents to sue owners who violate them. Section 10.3 of the agreement requires the successful party to recover reasonable attorney fees from the unsuccessful party. The Supreme Court found the lawsuit was directly tied to enforcing those restrictions, which made the fee award mandatory once its conditions were met. The Dryjas had replaced their air conditioning equipment in June 2021, and the new unit was installed in a different position on their patio.

Timeline

  1. June 2021: The Dryjas replaced their air conditioning equipment.

  2. 2025: The Arizona Court of Appeals upheld the denial of fees to the Dryjas.

  3. October 28, 2026: The Arizona Supreme Court issued its opinion reversing the denial.

Money Landscape

Legal costs in residential disputes can run well beyond the value of the underlying complaint, and fee-shifting clauses determine who bears them. This ruling reinforces that Arizona courts will enforce those clauses as written when a dispute falls within the scope of a community's governing documents.

If your home is governed by an HOA with a fee-shifting clause, a dispute over a nuisance complaint could carry legal costs that are recoverable from the losing side. Homeowners in such communities may want to review their CC&Rs and any assessment or dispute-resolution provisions with a qualified attorney.

The takeaway

Read your community's CC&Rs for nuisance rules and any attorney-fee provisions before a dispute begins. If a conflict arises, a conversation with a qualified real estate attorney can clarify what costs may be recoverable.

Further reading

For more on rental and community living costs, see Apartments coverage across the state.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Times of India.

Live Poll

Should the losing party in a neighbour lawsuit always pay the winner's legal fees?