Insurance Shopping Rises as Switching Savings Narrow

Households comparing auto, home, and renters policies are switching carriers more often as premium increases stabilize.

Updated on Nov. 9, 2026 in Insurance

Gouache-painted editorial illustration of a house key and a car key resting side by side on a cream surface, suggesting the choice between staying and switching insurance carriers.
J.D. Power reported that insurance shopping rose 13.2% in the third quarter of 2026 while switching climbed 5.1%, as premium increases stabilized. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Have you shopped around for a new auto or home insurance provider recently?

J.D. Power reported that insurance shopping and switching rose again in the third quarter of 2026, with overall shopping up 13.2% from the second quarter and switching up 5.1%. Households across the country who compare policies for auto, home, or renters coverage are the ones most directly reached by the shift.

Why it matters

Shopping activity has been climbing even as auto shopping growth has slowed from its elevated 2024 and 2025 levels, suggesting consumers are still actively looking for better rates. The pattern reflects pandemic-era cost pressures that pushed premiums higher, followed by rate actions that have since moderated and left fewer obvious savings from switching.

Overall insurance shopping rose 13.2% from the second quarter of 2026, while carrier switching rose 5.1%. Renters coverage shopping climbed 6.5% and home coverage shopping climbed 7.7% over the same period.

The players

J.D. Power

A data and analytics firm whose insurance tracking reports give consumers and carriers a read on how often households shop for and switch auto, home, and renters policies.

The details

Shoppers compare quotes from multiple carriers and sometimes move their policy when a competitor offers a lower premium for similar coverage. As rate increases slow, the gap between what a household pays and what an alternative carrier charges can narrow, which changes whether switching pays off. Auto insurance shopping increased quarter over quarter but was flat compared with the prior year, while property shopping has cooled more sharply and at times shown negative year-over-year growth.

Timeline

  1. Since 2020: pandemic-driven cost pressures pushed premiums and shopping higher.

  2. 2024 and 2025: auto shopping reached elevated levels.

  3. Q3 2026: J.D. Power reported the latest shopping and switching figures.

Money Landscape

Shopping and switching have risen since the pandemic-era premium increases that J.D. Power has tracked through its Signals series. The current quarter's gains come as carriers' rate actions moderate, which shifts the balance of savings opportunities for households.

Households comparing renters or home policies saw both shopping and switching rise in the third quarter, so reviewing your current premium against recent quotes can show whether a change could pay off. Because auto shopping growth has leveled off compared with prior years, the savings from switching may be smaller than they were during the peak period.

The takeaway

Insurance shopping is still rising, but the gains from switching carriers are narrowing as rate increases stabilize. Before changing policies, consider comparing quotes and speaking with a qualified insurance professional about your coverage needs.

Further reading

For more on how premiums and coverage choices work, explore Insurance coverage and pricing guides.

Live Poll

Have you shopped around for a new auto or home insurance provider recently?