Injury Claims Could Push Up Car Insurance Costs

Injury claims now make up 52% of auto insurance payouts, a shift that could affect premiums for drivers nationwide.

Updated on Nov. 7, 2026 in Insurance

Vector-style editorial illustration of a dented car door beside a plain cardboard carton on an open floor, in slate blue, cream, and coral.
Injury claims made up 52% of U.S. auto insurance payouts in 2025, up from 44% in 2022, and insurers say rising costs could push premiums higher for drivers nationwide. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you expect your car insurance premiums to rise over the next year?

Insurers paid more for bodily injury auto claims than for vehicle damage in 2025, with injury claims making up 52% of category payouts, up from 44% in 2022. Rising injury costs are a factor households may see reflected in future car insurance pricing.

Why it matters

Bodily injury claims occur about one quarter as often as vehicle damage claims but now drive a larger share of payouts, and the average personal auto injury payout has risen more than 30% in four years to exceed $30,000. Industry analysts cite medical inflation, changing treatment patterns, greater attorney involvement, and artificial intelligence as drivers, which can push up premiums for all drivers.

Bodily injury claims made up 52% of auto insurance payouts in 2025, up from 44% in 2022, and the average personal auto injury payout now exceeds $30,000. Medical expenses per injured person climbed about 33% between early 2023 and Q1 2026, from roughly $24,300 to $32,300.

The players

CCC

A provider of auto claims data and analytics whose findings on rising injury costs are relied on by insurers when evaluating claim trends.

Thomson Reuters

A global information company whose 2026 survey tracked how quickly law firms are adopting generative AI tools.

The details

Higher medical bills submitted on third-party injury claims raise the amount insurers must pay per claim, and those costs flow through the claims system into overall auto insurance pricing. Treatments such as platelet-rich plasma, which average $11,000 to $12,000 per injured person, and shockwave therapy, which typically involves eight to nine sessions, add to the total. Patients are also turning to these experimental treatments sooner, an average of 122 days after an accident, down from 166 days three years ago. Generative AI tools can help law firms summarize medical records, build treatment timelines, and draft settlement demands more quickly, which may increase the number and detail of claims insurers face.

Timeline

  1. Late 2022: Generative AI tools became widely available, and submitted medical expenses rose soon after.

  2. 2025: Bodily injury claims first exceeded vehicle damage payouts.

  3. Q1 2026: Medical expenses per injured person reached $32,300.

Money Landscape

Auto injury payouts have grown faster than vehicle damage payouts over the past several years, reversing a pattern in which property damage dominated claims costs. Higher per-claim injury costs are part of the broader upward pressure on car insurance prices that drivers have faced recently.

If insurers keep paying out more on injury claims, the cost pressure can show up in car insurance premiums for drivers generally, not only those involved in accidents. Drivers who renew coverage may want to compare quotes and confirm their liability limits with a licensed insurance agent or a qualified financial professional.

The takeaway

Injury claims now account for over half of auto insurance payouts, so rising medical and legal costs are a meaningful factor in future premium trends. Review your current auto liability limits at your next renewal and ask your agent how recent claim trends may affect your rate.

Further reading

For background on how these pressures reach premiums, see the Insurance section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by KTBS.

Live Poll

Do you expect your car insurance premiums to rise over the next year?