Alternative Credit Scores Face New Mortgage Rating Rules
Borrowers whose loans rely on alternative scores could see how their mortgages are funded change as rating criteria take shape.
Updated on Nov. 6, 2026 in Residential

Fitch Ratings is asking investors and industry participants for feedback on how it should rate residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) that use alternative credit scores to originate loans. Comments are due by November 16.
Why it matters
Mortgage lenders are increasingly able to use alternative scores such as VantageScore 4.0 alongside or in place of FICO classic, and rating criteria determine how the securities backed by those loans are priced and sold. How rating agencies treat these scores can influence the cost and availability of mortgage credit for households whose files are scored differently.
Fitch caps alternative-score loans at 10% of a securitized mortgage pool, and the government-sponsored enterprises have priced VantageScore 4.0 loans equitably with FICO classic. The number of originators using newly allowable alternative scores in the GSE market has grown notably.
The players
Fitch Ratings
A credit rating agency whose RMBS ratings influence how mortgage-backed securities are priced and sold to investors, which in turn affects mortgage funding costs for households.
VantageScore
A credit scoring model, including version 4.0, whose use by lenders for mortgage underwriting may expand borrowers' access to credit scores beyond FICO.
Morningstar DBRS
A credit rating agency that announced in April a process for converting VantageScore 4.0 into FICO score equivalents for rating purposes.
The details
Fitch is seeking comment on three scenarios: alternative scores used as a substitute for FICO classic, as a complement to it, or where lenders can choose among scores from fewer than all three credit bureaus. To test ACS as a complement, Fitch proposes comparing default rates, defined as loans 90 or more days past due. Fitch notes that alternative scores may lack the historical depth of FICO classic but offer other advantages that could make them useful alongside it.
Timeline
Nov. 16: deadline for feedback on the alternative credit score rating criteria.
April: Morningstar DBRS announced a process for converting VantageScore 4.0 into FICO-equivalent scores.
Money Landscape
The GSEs' equitable pricing of VantageScore 4.0 loans marks a shift in which credit scores lenders can use in the mortgage market. Rating criteria now being developed determine whether that shift carries through to the securities that fund home loans.
If you are shopping for a mortgage, ask your lender which credit score it uses to evaluate your application, since that choice can affect approval and pricing. Changes in how RMBS are rated could shift the cost of funding home loans over time, so it is worth reviewing your mortgage options with a qualified financial professional.
The takeaway
Alternative credit scores are gaining ground in mortgage securitization, and the rating standards Fitch sets will shape how that plays out. Note the November 16 comment deadline and ask a lender which credit score it uses if you are applying for a home loan.
What happens next
Fitch's comment period closes Nov. 16, after which the agency will consider the feedback it receives before finalizing any criteria.
Further reading
For broader context on home loans and how they are financed, see Residential real estate coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by National Mortgage News.




