Commercial Auto Insurance Losses Narrow in 2025
Fleet operators may see smaller premium hikes, though liability claim costs keep rising.
Updated on Nov. 4, 2026 in Insurance

Commercial auto insurers posted their best underwriting results since 2021 in 2025, with the net underwriting loss narrowing to $2.2 billion from $4.9 billion in 2024. Net premiums written rose 6% to $65.8 billion, a shift that matters to businesses that insure fleets and company vehicles.
Why it matters
Commercial auto remains unprofitable overall, but the improvement reflects faster premium growth and better physical damage results rather than a broad turnaround. Liability claim costs continue to rise under pressure from social and economic inflation, which keeps upward pressure on what fleet operators pay for coverage.
Commercial auto net premiums written reached $65.8 billion in 2025, up 6% from the prior year, while the average loss per claim climbed to $31,537 from $28,771 in 2024. Auto liability alone accounted for 77% of net premiums and posted an underwriting loss above $4.6 billion.
The players
Progressive Insurance Group
A major auto insurer that was the largest commercial auto writer in 2025, trimming its book by 5.7% as it adjusted pricing and exposure.
The details
Liability coverage, which pays for injuries and property damage a commercial vehicle causes to others, is driving most of the losses as more claimants are represented by attorneys and jury awards rise. Physical damage coverage, which pays to repair or replace the insured's own vehicles, produced an underwriting profit above $2 billion with a combined ratio of 83.2, partly because fleet monitoring and maintenance reduced accident frequency. Repair costs have also grown as vehicles add cameras, sensors and advanced driver-assistance systems. Because liability and physical damage are priced separately, a business can see its physical damage costs stabilize while its liability costs keep climbing.
Timeline
2021: Commercial auto last posted underwriting performance comparable to the 2025 results.
2024: Commercial auto net underwriting loss stood at $4.9 billion.
2025: Commercial auto underwriting results reached their best level in a decade.
Mid-year 2026: The commercial auto loss ratio hit its lowest point in five years.
Second-quarter 2026: Commercial auto pricing increases were the lowest in more than 10 years.
Money Landscape
The 2025 improvement brings commercial auto back to underwriting results last seen in 2021, after a 2024 loss of $4.9 billion. Pricing increases in the second quarter of 2026 were the smallest in more than a decade, which signals that the premium cycle is flattening.
Businesses that run commercial vehicle fleets may see premium growth slow as pricing increases shrink, though liability costs remain a pressure point. Fleet operators should review how their liability and physical damage limits and deductibles are structured, and discuss options with a qualified insurance professional.
The takeaway
Commercial auto is improving but still losing money overall, so the liability trend is the number to watch. Fleet operators should check their renewal timing and discuss coverage structure with an insurance professional before the next policy period.
Further reading
For broader context on how premiums and coverage costs are set, explore our Insurance coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Risk & Insurance.





