Favorite Stocks Lag Least-Loved Names by Wide Margin

Investors who lean on analyst buy ratings may be seeing their favored sectors trail the broader market.

Updated on Nov. 2, 2026 in Stock Picks

Isometric editorial illustration of a tilted wooden beam balanced on a steel fulcrum over a stack of cream bundles, in muted oxblood and teal.
Piper Sandler analysis shows Wall Street's most highly rated stocks have trailed its least-loved names by a wide margin over the past year. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Would you buy stocks that Wall Street analysts currently favor right now?

Wall Street's most highly rated stocks have been underperforming its lowest-rated stocks by a wide margin over the past year, according to an analysis by Piper Sandler. The gap ranks among the three most extreme periods of favorite-stock underperformance since the mid-1990s, a development that matters for U.S. investors who hold broad-market funds or follow analyst ratings.

Why it matters

Analyst buy ratings are often used as a shorthand for which stocks are expected to do well, so a sustained reversal of that signal can matter to anyone relying on professional recommendations. Historically, similar stretches have appeared when corporate earnings or the broader economy begin to shift, as they did around the dot-com deflation in 2000 and the economic bottom in 2009.

Piper Sandler compared the highest-rated stock in each of 11 sectors against the lowest-rated name, and the favorite-stock gap over the past year ranks among the three most extreme since the mid-1990s. Arista Networks and EchoStar drew buy ratings from more than 87% of analysts, while Prudential Financial and T. Rowe Price received none.

The players

Piper Sandler

A Wall Street investment bank whose research arm publishes analyst ratings that many investors use to gauge stock sentiment.

Arista Networks (ANET)

A networking equipment company whose stock was among the most highly rated by analysts over the period studied.

EchoStar (ECHO)

A satellite and telecommunications company whose stock was among the most highly rated by analysts over the period studied.

Prudential Financial (PRU)

An insurance and asset management company whose stock ranked among the least favored by analysts over the period studied.

T. Rowe Price Group (TROW)

An investment management firm whose stock ranked among the least favored by analysts over the period studied.

The details

Piper Sandler measured relative performance by pairing the highest-rated stocks in each sector with the lowest-rated names, using the share of professional analysts who rated each stock a buy as the measure of favorability. The top 10 most favored names were dominated by information technology and communication services stocks, which means the underperformance is concentrated in sectors that analysts had broadly embraced. Investors who track analyst consensus would have seen those favored names lag their less-loved peers over the period studied.

Timeline

  1. October 2000: Favorites faltered as the dot-com bubble deflated after a summer rally.

  2. February 2009: Low-rated cyclical stocks rebounded sharply as the economy bottomed out.

  3. October 2020: An economic-reopening trade was sparked by expected COVID-19 vaccine approvals.

  4. Past year: Highest-rated stocks underperformed, among the three most extreme periods since the mid-1990s.

Money Landscape

The current gap ranks among the three most extreme periods of favorite-stock underperformance since the mid-1990s, placing it in a historical range that has previously preceded shifts in market leadership. Comparable reversals in October 2000 and February 2009 each marked a change in which sectors led the market.

If you hold individual stocks or funds weighted toward highly rated technology and communication names, the past year's underperformance may be showing up in your returns. Reviewing how much of your portfolio sits in those favored sectors is a practical step to take with a qualified financial professional.

The takeaway

Analyst consensus is a signal, not a guarantee, and a strong buy-rating streak can reverse sharply when the economy or earnings shift. Check how concentrated your holdings are in the most-favored sectors, and discuss any changes with a qualified financial professional before acting.

Further reading

For more on how analyst ratings are used to pick individual shares, explore our Stock Picks coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Morningstar.

Live Poll

Would you buy stocks that Wall Street analysts currently favor right now?