Surplus Insurance Policies Have Doubled in Cost
Homeowners forced into surplus line coverage often face higher premiums and deductibles than those with traditional plans.
Updated on Oct. 6, 2026 in Insurance
Live Poll
Would you trust a surplus line insurance policy if traditional coverage was unavailable for your home?
Surplus line insurance premiums for residential properties doubled between 2018 and 2022 as more households move away from admitted insurers. The report from Climate Cabinet Education now calls for increased regulation of these products to protect consumers.
Why it matters
Climate-driven severe weather and wildfires have triggered widespread nonrenewals, leaving many households with no option but the more expensive, less-regulated surplus market. Unlike standard plans, these policies lack backing from state guarantee funds, increasing the financial risk for policyholders.
Surplus line premiums for residential properties doubled from 2018 to 2022, while Utah reported a 4.5% home insurance nonrenewal rate in 2025. The full impact of these costs remains an emerging concern as access to traditional coverage shrinks.
The players
Climate Cabinet Education
An organization that tracks policy and climate-related financial risks and recently released a report calling for tighter oversight of the insurance sector.
The details
Consumers who lose coverage from traditional admitted insurers often turn to the surplus line market as a last resort. Because these providers operate with fewer regulatory requirements, they typically charge higher premiums and enforce larger deductibles for the same or less coverage. Furthermore, these insurers are not required to contribute to state guarantee funds, which means there is no safety net for the household if the insurer fails.
Timeline
Surplus line premiums for home coverage doubled between 2018 and 2022.
Colorado established a FAIR plan insurance program in 2023.
Utah recorded a 4.5% home insurance nonrenewal rate in 2025.
Money Landscape
The reliance on surplus line coverage marks a departure from standard market stability, shifting more financial burden directly onto homeowners. This trend follows years of rising nonrenewal rates driven by environmental risks that have outpaced traditional insurance model assumptions.
If you are struggling to maintain coverage, review your policy details to confirm if it is an admitted or surplus line product, as the latter carries higher financial risks. Consult with a licensed insurance professional to discuss coverage options or potential eligibility for state-run insurance pools.
The takeaway
The move to surplus line insurance significantly increases your out-of-pocket costs and decreases your consumer protections. Review your current policy renewal notice immediately and confirm with your agent whether your insurer participates in state guarantee funds.
Further reading
For more on managing policy changes and industry shifts, visit our guide on Insurance.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Wyoming Public Media.
Live Poll
Would you trust a surplus line insurance policy if traditional coverage was unavailable for your home?
